Manager Denies a Previously Approved Medical Accommodation in California: Your Rights

Summary

If your manager withdraws a medical accommodation that your employer already approved, the change may violate California law. Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), covered employers generally must provide reasonable accommodations for known disabilities unless they can establish an applicable exception, such as undue hardship. An employer can reassess an arrangement when circumstances change, but a manager’s preference alone does not remove the employer’s legal duties. You can document the decision, ask for a written explanation, request a renewed interactive process, and seek legal guidance.

An earlier approval is useful evidence, but it does not mean an accommodation can never change. The central questions are whether the adjustment remains effective and reasonable and whether the employer has met its legal obligations.

Can a Manager Revoke an Approved Medical Accommodation?

Office worker with a forearm crutch pauses beside an accessible workstation.

Sometimes, but the employer must have a lawful basis for the decision. California Government Code Section 12940(m) requires covered employers to reasonably accommodate known physical or mental disabilities unless the employer demonstrates undue hardship. Section 12940(n) separately requires a timely, good-faith interactive process when the statutory requirements apply.

These employment disability protections generally cover California employers with five or more employees. Other laws may also apply, depending on the workplace and circumstances.

For example, an employee in Rancho Cucamonga, California, may have a modified schedule approved for ongoing treatment. A new manager who cancels it without evaluating the employee’s continuing restrictions or discussing effective alternatives may expose the employer to a legal claim. The outcome depends on the facts, not solely on which supervisor made the decision.

What Qualifies as an Approved Medical Accommodation?

An accommodation is a workplace adjustment that helps a qualified employee perform essential job functions or gain equal access to employment opportunities. Depending on the position and medical limitations, examples may include:

  • A modified schedule for treatment or medical appointments.
  • An ergonomic workstation or adaptive equipment.
  • Additional breaks related to disability limitations.
  • Changes to marginal, nonessential duties.
  • Remote work when compatible with essential job functions.
  • A period of leave or reassignment to a vacant position when legally appropriate.

Your employer does not always have to provide the exact accommodation you prefer if another available option is reasonable and effective. It generally does not have to eliminate essential job functions or create a new position.

For related employee protections, see California Retaliation Lawyers.

David P. Myers

Managing Partner

Adam N. Stern

Attorney

Ann Hendrix

Attorney

Robert Kitson

Attorney

Justin Crane

Attorney

Doug Smith

Attorney

Jason Hatcher

Attorney

Morgan J. Good

Attorney

Alvin Ferrara

Attorney

When Can an Employer Reconsider the Arrangement?

Reassessment may be appropriate when medical restrictions expire or change, essential duties materially change, an arrangement stops working, or reliable new information shows an undue hardship. The employer may also explore an effective alternative accommodation.

An individualized evaluation matters. An unsupported assumption that an employee cannot work, or a supervisor’s frustration with a schedule, does not by itself prove that the approved adjustment is unreasonable.

Key takeaway: A manager can raise concerns about an accommodation, but the employer remains responsible for evaluating the employee’s needs and complying with FEHA.

What Does the Interactive Process Require?

The interactive process is a timely, good-faith exchange between the employer and employee to identify effective accommodations. Under California Code of Regulations, Title 2, Section 11069, this may involve reviewing current restrictions, discussing barriers at work, and considering feasible adjustments.

For example, an employee in Ontario, California, may have a documented lifting restriction. If a supervisor wants the employee to resume heavy lifting, the employer should evaluate the medical restriction and possible alternatives, such as equipment or reallocating marginal tasks, rather than treating staffing pressure as a complete answer.

A failure to participate in the required interactive process can support a separate claim from a failure to provide reasonable accommodation. Each claim has its own legal elements.

What Should You Do When Your Manager Denies Your Accommodation?

You can take the following practical steps promptly. These are protective measures, not a legal requirement to act within a particular 24-hour or 48-hour period.

1. Request the Reason in Writing

Ask what changed and why the approved accommodation is no longer being honored. If the denial was verbal, send a respectful email describing the conversation and requesting clarification.

2. Preserve Your Records

Keep copies of materials you are lawfully entitled to retain, such as:

  • The original accommodation request and written approval.
  • Work restrictions and medical notes supplied to the employer.
  • Relevant emails, schedules, and duty assignments.
  • Records of meetings with managers or human resources.
  • Performance reviews and communications about the arrangement.

3. Ask Human Resources to Review the Decision

Explain that a supervisor has stopped an accommodation previously approved by the employer. Request confirmation of the current status and ask the employer to resume the interactive process when necessary.

4. Clarify Medical Restrictions When Appropriate

If your limitations have changed or the employer reasonably needs updated information, ask your healthcare provider whether a current work-restriction note would help. Disability-related documentation requests are subject to legal limits, and you generally do not need to disclose more medical detail than the law permits.

5. Seek Advice Before Taking a Risky Employment Step

Do not assume that resigning or refusing an assignment will preserve a legal claim. If an instruction conflicts with medical restrictions, explain the problem promptly, seek medical guidance when needed, and consider speaking with an employment lawyer.

Results

$2,300,000

Jury Verdict in Individual Retaliation

$3,300,000

Discrimination and Harassment

$2,750,000

Meal and Rest Break Class Action

$2,500,000

Off The Clock Work Class Action

$1,600,000

Disability Discrimination

$1,400,000

Discrimination and Retaliation

Can Your Employer Retaliate Against You for Repeating the Request?

California Government Code Section 12940(m)(2) prohibits retaliation or discrimination because a person requested a reasonable accommodation, whether the request was granted or denied. Possible signs include discipline, reduced hours, demotion, or termination linked to the request.

A close sequence of events can be relevant evidence, but timing alone does not establish retaliation. The employer’s stated reasons and the surrounding circumstances also matter.

Learn more about protected workplace activity on the firm’s California Retaliation Lawyers page.

Can You File a Claim if an Accommodation Is Withdrawn?

Depending on the evidence, a California employee may have claims for disability discrimination, failure to accommodate, failure to engage in the interactive process, or retaliation. These claims are fact-specific, and denial of a requested arrangement does not automatically establish a violation.

For many FEHA employment claims, you generally must file an administrative complaint with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD) within three years of the alleged unlawful act. A CRD complaint is ordinarily required before pursuing a FEHA lawsuit in court. If you obtain a right-to-sue notice, a one-year lawsuit deadline generally applies, subject to statutory exceptions and tolling rules.

Federal Americans with Disabilities Act claims use separate procedures and deadlines. Seeking legal advice early can help identify the correct agency and timing.

What Remedies Might Be Available?

Where a legal violation and resulting harm are established, available relief may include:

  • Back pay and lost employment benefits.
  • Compensation for proven emotional distress.
  • Reinstatement or other appropriate employment relief.
  • Provision of an effective accommodation or changes to workplace practices.
  • Attorney fees and litigation costs where authorized.
  • Punitive damages in legally qualifying cases.

The available remedy depends on the claim, supporting evidence, legal requirements, and actual losses. Some employees primarily want a workable accommodation restored so that they can remain employed.

Quote

I had some issues with my employer. I called a couple of law firms. Some called back and some did not. When David Myers returned my call I found him to be down to earth and personable. He was cognitive about my issues and his knowledge of Labor Law was exemplary. My issues were addressed and handled to my satisfaction. I will recommend David Myers and his law group to anyone who asks. Thank you David.”

- Ken Fretter

Quote

The Meyers Law Group is definitely the lawyer’s you want. We got absolutely misguided by another attorney firm and Maria helped us out and got us taken care of. Maria will take the time to completely understand your case and her knowledge is well beyond the many firms we sat with.Do not! I repeat, Do not! Use another firm without talking to The Meyers Law Group first.Thank you Maria for getting us the results we were expecting."

- Koa G.

Quote

I have hired David Myers for 2 cases. The first was a wrongful termination based on my request for a reasonable accommodation under ADA law. The second case involved an employer who reneged on a written job offer/acceptance. In both cases, David was knowledgeable about the laws, presented the case well, and was supportive of me. We prevailed on both cases. I would recommend David without hesitation."

- Anonymous

What if the Accommodation Involves a Workplace Injury?

A work injury may implicate both the workers’ compensation system and FEHA when the condition qualifies for disability-related protection. Receiving workers’ compensation benefits does not automatically end an employer’s separate reasonable accommodation responsibilities.

For instance, a Fontana, California, warehouse employee may return to work with medical lifting limits. If a supervisor disregards those restrictions, the employee may need advice about both workplace injury rights and disability accommodation obligations.

For more context, read Returning to Work After a Workplace Injury

Frequently Asked Questions About Revoked Medical Accommodations

Can My Manager Override an Accommodation Approved by HR?

A manager may participate in a lawful reassessment, but the employer still must comply with applicable disability laws. Personal disagreement alone is not enough to justify an unlawful withdrawal.

Does My Employer Have to Keep the Same Accommodation Forever?

No. Changes in medical restrictions, essential duties, or other material circumstances can justify reassessing an arrangement. The employer must still meet any applicable accommodation and interactive-process duties.

Does My Employer Have to Approve the Specific Accommodation I Want?

Not necessarily. Another reasonable and effective accommodation may satisfy the law, depending on the employee’s limitations and job requirements.

Should I Refuse to Work When My Accommodation Is Canceled?

Refusal to perform an assignment is not automatically protected in every situation. Communicate any conflict with medical restrictions, request guidance, and seek individualized legal advice before making a decision that may affect your employment.

Can I Be Fired for Asking to Restore My Accommodation?

An employer cannot lawfully fire you in retaliation for a protected accommodation request. Whether a specific termination was unlawful depends on the facts and applicable legal standards.

Related Videos

Choosing an Employment Law Attorney

Recovering Damages in an Employment Law Claim

Speak With a California Employment Attorney About Your Accommodation Rights

If an approved medical accommodation was canceled, you can seek a clearer explanation and advice about your options. The Myers Law Group represents California employees in disability discrimination, failure-to-accommodate, and retaliation matters. Its employment attorneys serve clients throughout California, including Rancho Cucamonga, Santa Barbara, and nearby areas.

Contact The Myers Law Group to discuss the circumstances and possible next steps.

This article provides general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

David P. Myers Avatar

David P. Myers is the founding partner of the firm and spends time at all three office locations.

In addition to representing individual employees, Mr. Myers also represented various unions, including the American Federation of Teachers, Communications Workers of America, the International Union of Operating Engineers, the Southern California Allied Printing Trades Council and the Teamsters.

Mr. Myers’ goal is to provide his clients with the type of representation that levels the playing field between the client and the employer.

Skip to content